The Grand Finale of Cassini

Originally published in the Informanté newspaper on Thursday, 21 September, 2017.


On Friday, 15 September 2017, at 11:55:46 UTC, the Grand Finale ended. The spacecraft Cassini entered and crashed into the atmosphere of the gas giant Saturn, and signal was lost. This was the final of 22 orbits, its ‘Grand Finale,’ as it entered the atmosphere about 10 degrees north of Saturn’s equator at a speed of over 120 000 km/h. For 13 years, Cassini has been sending back its remarkable readings and photographs of Saturn and its moons, and now its mission was finally over. 

So what has happened over the last 4 months during Cassini’s Grand Finale? In the first orbit, the Visible and Infrared Mapping Spectrometer (VIMS) as well as the Composite Infrared Spectrometer (CIRS) produced a movie of Saturn’s north polar region, including the planet’s hexagon jet stream for a full rotation of the planet. The second orbit provided the opportunity for the magnetometer to make high-intensity magnetic field observations of the planet for the first time ever. The Imaging Science Subsystem (ISS) simultaneously observed its rings while the sun was hidden, allowing the observations of faint ringlets. 

The third orbit provided the opportunity to use the Radio Science Subsystem (RSS) to perform gravity field measurements to study the interior of Saturn. The fourth has the ISS observe the most prominent ring propellers, while the RSS ran a gravity experiment to study the planet’s gravitational field. The Cosmic Dust Analyser (CDA) scooped up ring particles to determine their age. The fifth orbit continued the RSS and CDA experiments, while the ISS and CIRS observed and mapped the planet’s atmosphere. 

The sixth obit had the ISS takes pictures of Saturn’s rings, while the RADAR mapped the rings down to 100 meters per pixel. During the seventh orbit, the CIRS made high-resolution thermal scans of the rings while the RADAR continued its experiment. During the eight orbit, Saturn’s southern hemisphere was mapped. In the ninth orbit, the Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrograph (UVIS) observes Saturn’s northern aurora, while the Ion and Neutral Mass Spectrometer (INMS) measures the density and composition of particles in the ring plane. 

During the tenth orbit, the CIRS observes Saturn’s A ring to compare its ice with those of its moons. During the eleventh orbit, the UVIS studies the edge of the atmosphere – airglow, auroras and hydrocarbons – while the CIRS maps the temperature of the north polar vortex and the VIMS captures a movie of the southern polar vortex. In the twelfth orbit, the UVIS studies small scale structures in the rings, and in the thirteenth orbit, the CIRS observes the A ring to determine its composition and structure, while the ISS makes a high-resolution scan of the B and C rings. By now, Cassini is within 50 000 km of the atmosphere, and the INMS samples the planet’s exosphere and ionosphere. 

On the fourteenth orbit, the RSS performs its last observations as Cassini skims the atmosphere, while feeling the gravitational pull of the rings, determining their mass very accurately, while the VIMS observes Saturn’s southern hemisphere at night. In the fifteenth orbit, the UVIS observes the auroral zones on both poles, while the Radio and Plasma Wave Science (RPWS) captures ‘whistlers’ produced by the planet’s lightning. During the sixteenth orbits, both the UVIS and VIMS focus to produce high-resolution auroral images. 

The seventeenth orbit sees the ISS targeting Saturn’s ring propeller features, and marks the start of the end for Cassini. Only five orbits remain – the final five that are low enough to start passing through the atmosphere. During the eighteenth orbit, the CIRS observes the atmosphere’s edge to determine temperatures at different altitudes. The ISS observes the mysterious streaks in the C ring, while the INMS performs the first ever direct sampling of Saturn’s atmosphere. 

Less than a month is now left for Cassini. In the nineteenth orbit, CIRS observes temperatures in Saturn’s southern pole, while the VIMS stares at the southern auroras to produce a mosaic. During the twentieth orbit, the CIRS maps the northern hemisphere to study temperatures in the troposphere, while the VIMS maps the equatorial regions. The RADAR studies the atmosphere in active mode, while the INMS performs a second direct sampling of the upper atmosphere. In the twenty-first orbit, both the VIMS and the CIRS work together to study Saturn’s atmosphere, while the INMS made its third direct sampling as well. 

During the final, twenty-second orbit, the CIRS and VIMS together focused to determine the amount of helium in the atmosphere, while the INMS performs its fourth direct sampling from the atmosphere. The RADAR was focused on studying the ammonia in the atmosphere, while the ISS captured an iconic image of the rings as seen looking outward from Saturn. And so, the Cassini-Huygens missions that started on 15 October 1997 came to a close.


On 12 September, 2017, at 5h27 UTC, Cassini’s final plunge began. During its final days, data from the CIRS and UVIS were transmitted to Earth in real-time, seconds after each observation. By 15 September, 2017, at 10h31, thrusters were activated to maintain altitude control for its final minute. Thereafter, Cassini started to tumble into Saturn’s atmosphere, unable to maintain radio contact with Earth. Its final signals were received, after the 84 minute lightspeed delay of radio signals, at 11h55:46 by NASA’s Deep Space Network.

The total cost of the missions was a mere US$ 3.9 billion over the 20 years, costing about US$11 per American, US$1 per European and US$ 3 per Italian, the mission’s three main sponsors. A small price to pay for the wealth of information brought back. Cassini programme manager Earl Maize described the probe as a ‘superb machine’ that ‘to the very end did everything we asked.’ He continued, ‘Cassini has ended its mission high over the clouds of Saturn. Thanks and farewell, faithful explorer.’

Smoke and Vapour

Originally published in the Informanté newspaper on Thursday, 7 September, 2017.

During the past week, the Cancer Association of Namibia has responded to requests for information about the habit of ‘vaping’ or e-cigarette use, and appears to have only furthered the cause of the tobacco industry by creating even more fear, uncertainty and doubt. I rather doubt this was their intention, and rather attribute this to a rather convoluted message that did not clarify the facts they wished to present. As such, allow me to clear up the smoke and vapour surrounding this subject more clearly. 

Smoking is a serious health risk to Namibians. It is estimated that about 11.5% of females and 39% of males in Namibia smoke. Smoking increases the risk of coronary artery disease and stroke by 2 to 4 times, and the risk of developing lung cancer 25 times. This is a significant burden on any healthcare system, and specifically for a developing country such as Namibia. Any potential solution to reduce this burden should be strongly promoted. 

The health effects of tobacco smoking is thought to be well known, but even the Cancer Association does not make it clear that it is not the nicotine in cigarettes that cause cancer! After all, if that was the case, why would nicotine-replacement therapy devices be sold as an alternative? Nicotine patches, chewing gum – these have all been sold as ways to cut down on smoking. However, lest I be unclear – NICOTINE IS EXTREMELY ADDICTIVE. It is the reason why smokers keep on smoking. DO NOT TRY IT! 

Rather, it’s the other components of cigarette smoke that cause cancer – the so-called ‘tar’ in cigarettes, which in reality contains over 7000 different chemicals, some merely additives, some proven cancer-causing chemicals, and of course, the by-products of combusting the tobacco to consume it, namely carbon monoxide. The inhalation of carcinogenic substances is the obvious cause of the increased risk of lung cancer, but what about carbon monoxide?

Well, it’s rather well known that inhaling high concentrations of carbon monoxide is lethal, but low levels? Research indicates that carbon monoxide competes with oxygen to bind with haemoglobin, the cells that transport oxygen through the blood. Thus, with carbon monoxide binding to haemoglobin, there is less oxygen available to the body. Even worse, when haemoglobin releases the oxygen to myoglobin in the muscles, this causes carbon monoxide to be released instead, reducing the amount of oxygen the muscles can absorb and decreasing their ability to contract. This might not sound like much of a concern, until you consider that the heart is a muscle as well, and that this is how heart disease can gain a foothold. 

Now let us consider e-cigarettes. These devices work by heating a liquid containing nicotine until it vaporises, and can be inhaled. Notably, this still delivers nicotine, and I cannot stress this enough, NICOTINE IS EXTREMELY ADDICTIVE. It is considered as addictive as heroin. And it is the reason why smokers can transition from smoking cigarettes to smoking e-cigarettes – the core of the addiction is transferred.

But what about the other health effects? Let me then refer you to a paper – “Nicotine, Carcinogen, and Toxin Exposure in Long-Term E-Cigarette and Nicotine Replacement Therapy Users: A Cross-sectional Study,” by Lion Shahab, PhD; Maciej L. Goniewicz, PhD; Benjamin C. Blount, PhD; Jamie Brown, PhD; Ann McNeill, PhD; K. Udeni Alwis, PhD; June Feng, PhD; Lanqing Wang, PhD; Robert West, PhD, and primarily funded by Cancer Research UK. 

Their conclusion: “Former smokers with long-term e-cigarette–only or NRT-only use may obtain roughly similar levels of nicotine compared with smokers of combustible cigarettes only, but results varied. Long-term NRT-only and e-cigarette–only use, but not dual use of NRTs or e-cigarettes with combustible cigarettes, is associated with substantially reduced levels of measured carcinogens and toxins relative to smoking only combustible cigarettes.”

In other words, e-cigarettes, which do not combust tobacco to deliver nicotine, and as a result also don’t produce carbon monoxide, also significantly reduces the amount of carcinogens and toxins relative to smoking, as without combustion, it also does not deliver the ‘tar’ which contains said toxins. In other words, as reported by Public Health England’s 2015 report that the Cancer Association cited, e-cigarettes are 95% less harmful than tobacco. 

Note, however, that this does not mean SAFE. A 95% reduction in harm is significant, but that still means 5% of the harmful effects are still present. If you are currently a non-smoker, this does not mean you should try starting with e-cigarettes. As a reminder, NICOTINE IS EXTREMELY ADDICTIVE. E-cigarette still contain nicotine, and will leave you just as addicted as if you had started with cigarettes. It is here I believe the Cancer Association stumbled. In their attempt to discourage non-smokers from starting up a habit via e-cigarettes, they did a massive disservice to current smokers and, ironically, their own bottom line. Because, yes, if you’re currently a non-smoker, e-cigarettes are NOT something you should try. 

HOWEVER, if you are currently a smoker, for Celestia’s sake, PLEASE CONSIDER SWITCHING TO E-CIGARETTES. They are not completely safe, yes, but they SIGNIFICANTLY reduce the health risks associated with smoking. If you have smokers in your family, encourage then to rather switch to e-cigarettes for their health. Smoking cessation is difficult – after all, as we’ve established, nicotine is as addictive as heroin. I believe even the Cancer Association of Namibia would welcome a 95% reduction in lung cancer cases, and the public health infrastructure in Namibia would welcome a reduction in their caseload as well. 

Yes, cessation would be the best solution, but we do not live in an ideal world. We cannot do nothing if the best solution fails. Tobacco harm reduction is becoming an acceptable strategy worldwide to deal with the adverse health effects of smoking. Let us apply it here, in Namibia, as well – after all, if we can reduce the 1 700 estimated yearly tobacco deaths in Namibia to a mere 85, we’d have saved a lot of lives. A quit or die approach helps no-one.